The formation placed Jordan Henderson in the pivotal role behind the striker with Gerrard and Adams the creative forces in the engine room and Stewart Downing to provide the width. If we had taken the lead earlier on, with Adam inexplicably missing when in front of the goal from a Gerrard corner, then we may well have been on our way. But in a season full of ifs, the die was cast with the play becoming staid as if the players have become typecast from starring in the same production.
Downing as a winger has become a player seemingly trapped in the expectation to do well and is now not delivering on either the right or the left. On the left, his crosses lack pace or penetration and on the right he invariably checks back to deliver a nothingness. The quandary for Dalglish is that with Bellamy’s inability to start two consecutive games there is a propensity to pick him even though his form has now dipped to unacceptable levels where he fails to commit and attack full backs which is a crying shame in a game where Gerrard and Adam constantly delivered cross field balls of the highest quality which any top class winger would have run onto with abandon. His failure was accentuated because of the failure of Enrique and Johnson, who both saw plenty of the ball, to deliver quality end product in the final third.
Today’s was chronic on many different levels. That we picked Carragher and Coates sent out a message that we worried about Stoke’s physicality, but more worrying was that we were playing at home. Also, to say that his (Dalglish) hands were forced following Agger’s injury, intimates that Carragher cannot cut in alongside Skrtel or he doesn’t think Coates is ready.
For the manager to say at the end of game that we suffered with a lack of creativity is hard to take when it had it with his hands to change the formation at half time, by pushing Johnson forward and bringing on Kelly for a centre-half and pushing Gerarrd behind the striker and giving Bellamy on with time to change the game against Stoke side which offered nothing in attacking sense.
The last remaining opportunity, of a disappoint match, fell to Kuyt who failed to capitalise on a glorious chance, heading the ball wide when it seemed easier to score. We failed to create too many chances in the final third without Carroll on the pitch – but I guess critics will still blame him. Liverpool needs a clinical striker who is capable of eking out chances for himself if we continue to play in the same way with a lack of penetration and movement at home.
With the team playing so disappointingly and the lack of creativity for all to see and with some of the most talented youngsters in the country in the reserves why isn’t the manager at least finding a spot on the bench to offer something different and inject some energy?
No excuses. We are throwing away an opportunity to finish in the top four which we may just find it harder to come by next season. By the time we play our next game we may just being out of the top six.
Kop-Post Man of The Match: Charlie Adam – although offering relatively little in attack, some of his cross field passing was like a laser guided missile.
Followed the commentary on sky/eurosport and I have gotten to a point where I refuse to comment on Liverpool FC. How can we have drawn 7
ReplyDeletegames at home, we dont score goals, Carroll is a dud.. we need someone to come in during this window, we play well in almost every department
but lack that all important cutting edge I have given up on this season, the only hope I have is that we stand a chance of making the carling cup final and that is with a bit of luck.
I may have BA as part of the package to return Andy to Newcastle, who incidentally are above us on the table. If we took 3 points last Saturday, with Arsenal slip up we would have been 2 points clear in the 5th place right now.
DeleteIf we don’t capitalise on the teams around us dropping points it makes no difference if Arsenal/Chelsea/Newcastle win or lose they are all in better positions than us at the moment for 4th place.
Deleteand also... because our rivals for 4th place are just as likely to drop points – there is still hope but we do need a striker and a creative spark to help Carroll or whoever plays upfront to start scoring.
DeleteSorry David, I can see us getting the 4th place. We are just not good enough. There're 3 strong contenders for the 4th place as you rightly named we're not part of it. I have long turned off my expectation from us finishing 4th, I can't see it happening given our current home form and lack of goal in the team.
DeleteYou certainly appear to have SO MUCH faith in Andy, I am not.
DeleteAndy Carroll should be packed off to the glue factory like the clapped out cart horse he is. Bruce Grobbelaar was on talk sport this morning and said that we are looking to bring in two strikers but he’s probably talking rubbish. I doubt that Brucie is in the inner circle.
DeleteSurprised nobody handed Sami a shirt and got him on the pitch too just to see if we could set some sort of record for most central defenders playing at once.
DeleteYes Stoke are tall guys and they’ve got Delap and blah blah blah… but that was so negative. I’ve always rated Crouchy but surely he’s not THAT incredible that he needs 3 markers!?!
Watched it on the weekend highlights show over here and I’m pretty sure the only reason they even showed it on the highlights show is because Coates played.
Robert
I watched all 90 soul sapping minutes, it was the worst performance since Kenny took over by a mile. I agree with Karl that although we all love Kenny he shouldn’t be beyond reproach, his tactics and decisions stunk the place out on Saturday, not calling for his resignation or anything and I know that we are a work in progress but that was really poor.
DeleteSorry but this is a missed opportunity for me. Chelsea and Arsenal are faltering and with a few home wins we would have been right behind Spurs. Work in progress... come next season when the Chelsea, Man City and Manu United cheque books go into overdrive where will we be? How difficult has it been for us to buy top class players over the last few years not playing in the Champions League!?!
DeleteI was reading an Eden Hazard interview after being linked with us, he gave the impression that if he was to leave it would be Barcelona, Real Madrid and if he came to England Chelsea or one of the other two in the order. Not a mention of us.
Anyone can have a bad game, but even forgiving the missed opportunity Dirk was awful, he looked like a plodder and Jordan Henderson playing behind the frontman looked a fish out of water and Charlie looks like he has an aversion to going forward.
No ambition in the last two games first against Man City in the first leg of the Carling Cup semi final at the Etihad Stadium where we end up with a 7-3-0 formation and now yesterday playing both Coates and Carragher because we were worried about the attacking threat of Stoke's long throw and prowess at set-pieces.
ReplyDeleteCurrently we have no cutting edge -playing too many defensive players and playing with several players out of confidence and are suffering in the league because of it.
I said this before, but I Liverpool are in a quandery. The most potent force in the team at the moment is Bellamy who can't play two successive games because his injury has to be managed and Gerrard just coming back from injury. I say again, how can one of your most potent weapons only start one game in maybe every three or so, and there is no capable replacement?! And in Maxi you have a midfielder who seems to know where the onion bag is, yet his starts are being managed because of his age.
DeleteRight now Downing, Adam and Henderson are struggling to create or score goals which hindering the teams progress. Adam at times looks like the poor man's David Silva unable to deliver in the final third and in Henderson I believe his best position is centre midfield and not on the right or behind the front man as he was yesterday.
Yesterday, Downing who as I said in the blog is just not hitting the standards required was taken off and replaced by the man he was bought to supply crossing too which one says how bad he is playing and two is hard to understand. Carroll didn't receive decent service in the time he was on. If we had had Robin van Persie up front yesterday he would have struggled with the supply that was on offer. For Dirk Kuyt to start ahead of Carroll just accentuates the muddled thinking of Dalglish and Clarke from the perception of fans.
This side is woefully short of pace, which is won of the reasons why Bellamy is missed so much. Suarez creates a good percentage of his changes by himself and that's not what we're going to get with Suarez and to a lesser extent a Dirk Kuyt on his best form. If there is no attacking or creative force in the reserves then questions need to be asked because we have spent a hell of a lot of money in the past few years and one would of thought that one of these players is capable of holding down a spot on the bench, slongside Shelvey, whether it's Suso, Sterling or a Morgan.
Well that was a bit depressing. 5 defenders on against stoke is never going to produce exciting fayre but Gawd that was brutal to watch. Kenny got his line up wrong but the most frustrating thing was the substitutions – Bringing Carroll on and taking off the man whose meant to be providing the crosses was baffling, could we not have hooked a defender instead? Papers now saying that we are going to blow £10 million on Defoe, correct me if I’m wrong but was he not blamed for missing guilt edge sitters and contributing to Spurs paucity in front of goal last season? Surely we don’t need another striker that can’t hit a barn door. Surely £10 million could be spent more wisely, what is Comolli doing if the best idea he can come up with is Jermain ‘jdizzle’ Defoe????? The mind boggles.
DeleteIt is really not good enough and we all know that if it wasn’t for who the manager is right now – we would be asking major questions about his capability to do the job right now.
DeleteWe may go on to win the Carling Cup this season but the bread and butter for a major European force is to qualify for the Champions League and be very competitive at the top end of the table in your domestic league – under Kenny so far we are not competitive and if that doesn’t change by the first 3 months of next season by for example - December 2012 we are gonna have to start seriously thinking of another manager.
We can not just be happy with aiming for 4th and 5th every year that is not ambitious for me and not the way I was brought up supporting this club – 1st should be our main target every season not settling for 4th place.
As KopPost said before the season started we should really be looking to win the title this season as others had the distraction of the Champions League and European football – we haven’t had that – we have been able to get the team training together near enough every week but still it seems like some of the players are strangers with each other – we are past half way in the season and still Andy Carroll has to tell players how he wants to receive the ball – its just not acceptable for me.
We are now 6 goals behind Blackburn in goal scoring that is also unacceptable for me. Players need to stop talking about it being unacceptable and start earning their money as hearing them talking about (we have to do better in home games) isn’t cutting it with me anymore.
Kenny had a nightmare. His selection was baffling and people didn’t seem to know where they were meant to be playing. The best part of the game was at half time when Sammy Hypia came on the pitch to raptous applause!
DeleteHorrific match to watch and some extremely questionable tactical decisions from kenny - as poor as carroll has been I think it is madness not to have started him on saturday and to have tried to give him a good run of games to try and get bit of confidence. Pretty damning inditement being left on bench of in favour of guy who hasn't scored a goal all season. As i read somewhere our front three on saturday have only scored one more league goal combined than tim howard!
DeleteAlso, agree that it was madness not to sacrife a centre half in second half when it was totally apparent Stoke were posing no threat what-so-ever....
My patience with downing is starting to wane rapidly as he seems scared to lose the ball and as a result adds virtually nothing to our play - it is so frustrating as he looked a totally different player for Villa last season - albeit not one worth £20mill!
Having said all this I think bit of perspective is needed and whilst our home record is abysmal and lack of goals is a massive concern I think so far in the context of this season this performance was a bit of an abberation. We are obviously someway short of where we want to be, are crying out for added attacking dynamism and look to be lumbered with two extremely costly errors in the transfer marker but when considering where we were 12 months ago i think kenny has earned a modicum of patience not because of who he is but because of the state the club was in when he took over and because of the majority of performances under his stewardship suggesting we are heading in the right direction - albeit with a few inevitable set-backs along the way.....
Very good analsis Luke - patience is needed I agree but Kenny can't change tact and start going defensive now - he must know that we can't continue not getting in the Champions League and expect to improve the quality of players coming in.
DeleteShambles, just reminds me Raffia times… we cannot even put a good home win display, against an average side.
ReplyDeleteAgain we missed chance on chance; we dented an opportunity to moving into the Premier League's top five.
Kuyt not his best– apart from best chance heading Jose Enrique's deflected cross wide from eight yards, what a miss.
We seemed to be restricted to long-range efforts, rather than playing the ball towards the stokes goal, no throttle, and all Carroll's was doing was falling like a pony and calling for hopeful penalty shouts.
With Kuyt on his own, Stoke pretty much nailed and drilled there defence and nothing was going past them.
These opportunities missed for taking three points just shows how we are suffering and only us to blame.
My theory in football is ifs and would haves and could haves don’t mean a thing – what matters is what you do.
DeleteAt the moment what we do is not good enough !!!! No cutting edge, no creativity, not enough goals – not good enough full stop.
Just got a text from LFC membership team saying that you can win a signed shirt from Dirk Kuyt – sorry that’s not a prize worth winning if he can’t put easy chances away to win us 3 points!!!!
DeleteAt the moment, I’m not really looking for any more Liverpool shirts or kits, I’ve found it difficult to wear what I’ve got in recent weeks.
DeleteTotally agree !!!
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteHey, wasn't Swansea a delight to watch against Arsenal? Wow!!!!!!!!!!!
ReplyDelete