Saturday, 6 July 2013

Board Constraints Could Stop Liverpool Competing



So it seems we’ve been barking up the wrong tree. Liverpool Football Club is still the 9th richest club in world football, which is some going considering that up until January 23 we were 5th in the Premiership for attendance with 44,674 (536,089).  Credit where credit is due, John W Henry and co have steered the good ship LFC away from the economic iceberg which countrymen Hicks and Gillet almost dashed our hopes on.

Or has it?  The annual accounts revealed that the club’s debt rose to £87.2 million.  While the annual loss was £40.5million (down £8.8million on the previous year), the loss shows the impact a continuous lack of Champions League football has had, the overall debt has risen by £22million.

That being said, it throws even more light on our transfer policy.  Great play has been made of club policy in acquiring top young talent, but it seems economic prudence is the marker by which the board stipulates is paramount to any transfer.  The board placed a set price on Ince and Coutinho  and refused to go much beyond their valuation. While economically that’s an admiral stance to take, unfortunately making a football club viable and then become a winner to boot just doesn’t cut the mustard, unless as in Germany, every club, in theory, sings from the same hymn sheet.

Man United, League winners by twelve points and ahead of us by a massive 28 points, have arguably the two of the top five players in the league, but it still hasn’t stopped them from splashing out £15million on Wilfried Zaha who many observers believe to be one of the most exciting home grown youngsters in years and on the verge, as I’m writing, of signing the brilliant Barcelona and Spanish under-21 captain Thiago.  By all accounts they were looking at re-signing the mercurial Ronaldo.

Was the price too rich for LFC blood or did Iain Ayre and Brendan Rodgers just not rate the player, so we didn’t even enter the race for Zaha or Paulinho? The club’s stance on Thomas Ince was easy to understand as there’s the embarrassment factor of paying a huge sum for a player who until recently was on the Anfield books and next summer will be available on a free transfer which throws up too many internal questions.

How is Brendan Rodgers supposed to keep pace with Fergusson, Mourinho, Pellegrini and with Wenger seemingly about to let the moths out of the Arsenal wallet,  knowing that he’s not allowed to enter the ball park marked top players or the ball park marked exceptionally talented youngsters?  A tad unfair don’t you think to manage with one hand tied behind his back?  FSG   could justifiably say “once bitten, twice shy” with Allen, Borini, Henderson, Downing and Carroll costing almost £100million and failing to set the world alight.

Are we trying to get back to the top on the cheap or making sure the mistakes of yesteryear do not return to destabilise us? Have we been banished from the top table by the inadequacies of our own board or is this just the culmination of years of miss-management finally catching up with us and we are now as one blog follower Livi said, “feeding off crumbs from the big table”?

The club’s debt rose by £21.8 million to £87.2 million in the 10 months between August 1 2011 to May 31 2012.  Even if the losswas substantially less than the previous year’s £49.3million and that’s taking on board the fact we got to the two domestic finals it’s still a substantial increase.

Managing Director Ian Ayre claims that even £9.5million of “exceptional payments” which included the pay-off to Kenny Dalglish will not hinder the club movements into the transfer market.  The board pumped an interest free inter-company loan into the Liverpool coffers to keep the debt at a manageable level to stave off the threat of another few seasons of not challenging for a Champions League position let alone winning the Premiership.

While I’m not saying that Liverpool Football Club should throw money around like confetti destabilising the club’s future, both Rodgers and the Board are correct in their assertion that the need to re-build the foundation and structure of the club was intrinsic to its future, but the other teams will not stand still.   The board, I believe have missed the boat in their determination to realigned the club using UEFA’s fair play rules as the barometer  because the massive increase in Premiership money will still keep the bigger clubs top of the pile.

On the face of it the Premier Leagues new financial regulations has strengthen Liverpool’s stance with clubs potentially penalised with a points deduction if they make a total loss of more than £105million over the next three seasons, in  addition, player wages will be curtailed from next season.  Incidentally, if these regulations had been in force over the last three seasons preceding the last one, LFC would have been punished with a points deduction  after reporting losses of over £105million (with Chelsea and Manchester City over that period).

The club having rid itself of many of its high wage earners before the 2012-13 season, is preparing for the new guidelines which state clubs whose total wage bill is over £52million will only be allowed to increase their salaries by an accumulative £4million over the next three seasons.

It’s difficult to see how these regulations can be enforced with the spending power of the Manchester clubs and Chelsea where advertising revenue can be raised to levels which will make up for any shortfall which shouldn’t be difficult given the rarefied atmosphere these clubs operate in, particularly taking into account the curb on wages only applies to television revenue.

The club finishing last in 2012-2013 received £60 million (rising from £39 million) which is the same as Man City earned for winning the Premiership in 2012, which means the prized Champions League places will have grown exponentially.  By 2014, depending on the level of overseas television income, the Premier League winners could receive somewhere between £90 and £110 million.

If one takes future Premiership revenue into account, and then looks at our lost revenue on match day compared to Arsenal and Man United and the probable ways of getting round UEFA’s rules like the signing of massive one off contracts under the guise of advertising revenue we still trail along way behind.  As I said, the brilliant work by the board in terms of the club’s off the field activities is keeping Liverpool, although a long way behind, on the same lap as the big boys, but where the Manchester clubs and Chelsea will again have the advantage is their continuation year on year in the Champions League and it’s why we need to breach that gap sooner rather later.

This is why I believe FSG are naïve in their belief that Financial Fair Play will lead to a level playing field.  Ian Ayre stated, “The recent rules that we’ve adopted at the Premier League will expect people to break even and limit their spending and player wages.  We will conform just as everyone else does.

“We’ve been a big advocate in pushing for that so we’re certainly not going to fall foul of it.”  Does Mr Ayre really think because LFC are subscribing to the news rules the imbalance will change?

It will be interesting to see whether the Premier League sanctions points reduction for teams who fail to comply with the new regulations.

Arsenal announced profits of £17 million in the six months leading up to November 2012 which bolstered their cash reserves up to a staggering £120 million.  When you consider that the club invested £40.9 million on four new players and extended players contracts it has to be said that Arsenal are pinning all their hopes on financial fair play.  Chairman, Peter Hill-Wood said ‘These new rules will be good for us, good for the Premier League and good for the game as a whole.

'It is important that we maintain the quality and level of competition if the game is to continue being a compelling spectacle and we believe the introduction of tighter financial regulation will assist all clubs to compete while remaining financially responsible.'

Its admiral thinking, but the lifeblood of any club is its fans and the announcement of stockpiles of cash will only make the losses of Robin van Persie, Samir Nasri and Cesc Fabregas with the replacements of inferior models more painful.  While Arsenal made the Champions League another trophy less season is hard to bare for Gooners fans.
The Arsenal Supporters' Trust (AST) said the figures highlighted the need for the club to spend more money on team strengthening.

An AST spokesman said: 'These figures contain few surprises. They show that Arsenal yet again made a profit from the sale of their best players and that the club has large cash reserves. 'Arsenal fans have contributed to this financial health through paying some of the highest ticket prices in world football. A further improvement in the club's financial strength is expected when new TV monies and commercial deals come on stream in 2013 and 2014.  AST members want to see this money used for more, and better, investment in the team'.

Top players these days want to sign for teams who qualify for the Champions League, while Fabregas may have left Arsenal to ‘go home’, the loss of van Persie is more keenly felt as he left the club to win silverware, and  did so in his first season at Old Trafford, which sends out a massive message.

Moreover, just as Arsenal lost van Persie, there is the huge possibility of us losing Luis Suarez.  I hear the arguments that we replaced Keegan with Dalglish, but the difference was that then we were the premier team in Europe and had the choice of the cream in terms of the top British players of the time.

Suarez is now seen as the replacement for Torres, although he was originally bought to play alongside the Spaniard and Suarez has admitted the thought played a large part in his signature.  With Gerrard now in his 34th year, Suarez is the world-class light the club needs to pull in other talent and right now we are in the position where we have to push on or languish amongst with the also rans.  If Suarez leaves a player of equal standing must be brought in if we are not to languish among the also-rans.  Paulinho, on the verge of signing for Spurs said recently, "To play in England for a great team like Tottenham is a dream. What I respect about Tottenham is the ambition they have shown.

"This summer there has been interest in their coach and their best player - and they have been clear they are both not going anywhere."

Conversely, FSG are releasing funds, though not at the top end of the market, it’s been enough for Rodgers to buy-in quality like Sturridge and Coutinho who at the moment seem relative bargains and Iago Aspas and Luis Alberto who may well be more of the same.

Borussia Dortmund have a proven track record for building teams over the years without shopping at the top end of the market, by concentrating on quality and with a proven breeding ground for bringing young players through their much vaunted youth set up and pinpointing talented South Americans, rather than stressing the need to spend £30 million on one player is a much better way, for them, to approach the transfer market. Thus it is possible to go against the grain. The difference is that Liverpool are up against three world super powers in their own backyard, hence by the time the youth team becomes the potent force the owners would like it to be, the gap to the top three could turn out to be as wide as the Laurel Canyon.

Bayern Munich’s mantra is to have a good business you need a good team… says it all doesn’t it.

The club needs to make a statement of intent, by buying in a recognise world-class talent, if Suarez is to leave, the talent coming in needs to be more than one of that ilk.  The pressure is now on Brendan Rodgers, having seen the club improve dramatically in the second-half of his first season. 
If Liverpool fail abysmally to get into the top four next season, I’m afraid Rodgers will have to go, because he and the board have maintained their mantra of only buying in a particular type of player with sell on value and as such can only be measured, as they should be, by the results of those players and not by the fact that have not made big money buys. 
 
The transfer market is open and we will see whether we can compete with Arsenal and Tottenham and for that matter the “big three”.

Ayre said recently, “We can still attract top players to Liverpool – I have no doubt about that.”

“I have never been in negotiations with anyone who has said they want to sign for Liverpool, because we are not big or successful enough.

“We’re focused on finding great young talent but we also need experience and leadership. It’s about getting the right balance.” 
 
Let’s see if the club lives up to his words or it proves to be yet another false dawn.

Wednesday, 3 July 2013

Season Review 2012-2013


Pepe Reina: The Spaniard's cloak of invincibility slipped even further this season, not helped by his propensity for silly mistakes, some of which proved costly. The Man City draw comes to mind at a time when Liverpool were looking to propel themselves forward for a bite at the Champions League apple.  The worrying factor for the manager was that his world-class keeper could barely stay fit during the first-half of the season, worryingly picking up different muscular injuries along the way.  His concentration levels seemed off kilter with the constant speculation of a move to Barcelona, gathering steam after his father's comments of a possible move and Victor Valdez stated wish to move away from the Catalan giants to eek out further challenges. Will be interesting to see if the fan's favourite becomes the second member of his family to keep goal for Catalan giants.   Should he leave, which is more than possible after the recent purchase of Simon Mignolet, we will miss his leadership which will leave an almighty gap with the retirement of Jamie Carragher.   4/10

Brad Jones:  Apart from the odd blemish, the Australian stopper followed on from the previous season serving the club with distinction.  He played in more games in 2012-13 than he could have imagined and although one would struggle to find a place for him in the top twenty-five goalkeepers in the Premiership, his conviction to the cause and bravery should not be under stated and his progress was recognised with the signing of a new long-term contract in December.  6/10

Glen Johnson:  Upped his consistency levels to such an extent, that he is now the best English right-back  by some distance.   The marked improvement defensively showed up

particularly in one on one's and his covering across the backline. Unfortunately, he fell away in a few performances toward the end of the season when his concentration wavered, either not putting in a challenge or being beaten on the back post in the air, which is disappointing when one considers the player's physique and his height at 6ft 2in.  It should not detract from a stellar season and one looks forward to further improvement as he seems to have reached his peak.  8/10

José Enrique: An improved performer this season showing the form he displayed in the first half of his initial season.  As with Johnson, he attacks with purpose and often linked up with Suarez to devastating effect.  He has shown his passing is both short and long range and his distribution can often be quite clever.  Like Johnson, if he could eradicate the odd silly mistake from the defensive part of his game, which is purely down to concentration and a propensity to hold on and occasionally loose the ball in dangerous areas, he could well develop into one of the foremost left-backs in the Premiership. 7/10

Daniel Agger: The Dane's talents have never been in question as a ball playing centre-half, but this last season was underwhelming.  Where at the start of the season the expectations levels were high following the Danish captain's statement of intent not to ply his trade elsewhere, his performances were less than stellar, but more disappointing for a national captain was his failure to show leadership of any consequence.  In fact, the defence only hinted at any cohesion with the addition of Jamie Carragher.  Next season will be the most important of his Liverpool career as the focal point of the defence and will determine whether he could be a future club captain. 5/10

Martin Skrtel:  His performance in the away game at Southampton was systematic of a player whose confidence levels had hit rock bottom.  Brendan Rodgers lack of faith in the Slovakian can't have helped a player who at his best has a host of admirers around Europe and was Liverpool's player of the season for 2011-12.  His recent comments, supplemented by his agent's, suggest, sadly, we may just be seeing the watershed of his Liverpool career.  3/10

Sebastian Coates:  If ever a player suffered from a lack of support its Coates.  Still only 22 years old, he arrived from Nacional in August 2011 with great fanfare having been voted the best young player at the 2011 Copa America.  There is no denying he has been disappointing in his appearances in a Liverpool shirt appearing to struggle with the physicality of the Premiership.  He would though have benefited from being loaned out or been given a longer stint in the first team, but sadly, he is another whose Liverpool career seems to have run its course.  0/10

Jamie Carragher:  His competitive edge has never wavered despite not quite being at his combative best moving toward the end of his career, but the club's vice-captain still managed to usurp Martin Skrtel and had the manager and others clamouring for him to overturn his decision to retire at the end of the season. .  His performances have struck a chord to remind us the standards required to be a Liverpool centre-half, let alone to play for the club.  Alex Fergusson tribute to Carragher said it all, "He's absolutely a player I admire," Sir Alex told the club's official website. "He's the epitome of a loyal, dedicated player who Liverpool have been lucky to have for more than a decade.

"He's been a bedrock of their defensive qualities for years and years. I loved him. He's a fantastic example for any young lad that wants to play the game. He's been a really, really good professional."

Carragher struggled for appearances in the first half of the campaign but has started 14 of Liverpool's last 16 Premier League games, and Sir Alex compared the centre-back to former United captain Steve Bruce.

"He's absolutely the type of player a manager wants," Sir Alex continued. "I used to rave about Brucie [Steve Bruce] and the nine years he had with us, and I think Jamie Carragher is that exact same mould - can play with injuries, gets knocked about and gets back up, hardly misses a game.

A true club legend.  6/10

Martin Kelly:  Started the season buoyed after becoming a late inclusion in the Euro 2012 squad, he was struck down for the second season in succession with a long-term injury, just as he seemed destined to hold down a first team place.  Whether his future is at right-back or centre-half is an interesting question for the pacey defender, but what is not in question is how highly rated he is at the club.  He signed a new long-term contract in February.  N/A

Andre Wisdom:   Robust in the tackle and showed enough maturity to make many observers forget that he is a centre-half by trade.  Martin Kelly's return may just hasten his move back to a central berth, but he let know one down with his performances and what was overlooked is just how comfortable he is on the ball.  If Brendan Rodgers is looking for depth at centre-half for next season he could do no worse than the Leeds born defender.  6/10

Joe Allen:  By the end of last season his £15million price tag seemed to be weighing down on him to such an extent that it appeared to be stifling his performances.  But, as we now know, the ex-Swansea midfield controller was playing with a shoulder injury.  It makes it all the more surprising and misguided that Brendan Rodgers continued to play the Welshman, with his level of performance being so poor, than one wondered whether he had any business being at the club.  Midfield is an area that Liverpool are over endowed  and as such there was no need to take such a risk.  Encouragingly, he managed to score his first league goal for Liverpool, but with Steven Gerrard and Lucas Leiva the dominant midfielders and with the club seemingly on the lookout for external talent, the cold realisation is that drive and power is a requirement in the engine room, and as such the 'little man' will have to up his game with additional elements to remain in the first eleven.  4/10

Lucas Leiva:  Steven Gerrard's improved form in the second half of the season was in no small part to Lucas finally getting over his long-term knee injury.  It allowed Gerrard to escape the shackles of holding the midfield together and becoming more of an attacking force, linking up with Coutinho and Suarez.  Lucas work in front of the defence should not be underestimated, as much as his play is understated, he makes countless interceptions and has added a variety of subtle passing to his armoury.  A fit Lucas at the beginning of the season and a Daniel Sturridge in toe may just have helped us to build a winning momentum through the season. In saying that, whether he is and can make the leap to become top class is open to question.  6/10

Jordan Henderson:  Impressed many during the season with performances hinting a long-term career at the club is not beyond him.  His team mate’s celebration following his stunning volley against Norwich showed just how much they recognise his whole hearted approach, often bursting through to support the striker and adding vitality to the midfield.  He showed tremendous strength of character to come back from ferocious criticism the previous season and one detected warmth among the Anfield faithful for a player who was voted England under-21 Player of the Year for 2012 by supporters and captained England under-21 at the European Championships. 6/10

Stewart Downing:  Another who showed fantastic fortitude to raise his game and put in some potent performances adding some much needed goals to his output.  Was on his way out of Anfield with 18 months’ worth of disappointing performances wearing thin the patience of his manager, who in a un-Liverpool like manner criticised the player in public, stating the player could move on in January.  Downing to his credit, fought back not just verbally, but displayed his best form since his arrival at the club in July 2011.  One sensed the player knew he was in the last chance saloon and operated accordingly.  His improved form might be enough to keep him as an important squad member, but as Rodgers seeks to improve Liverpool in his second season, he may struggle to hold down his first team place.  5/10

Steven Gerrard:  The England captain enjoyed an injury free season, but unlike his halcyon days, he understandably played in a more measured and less dynamic way, controlling the tempo of games and turned defence into attack with stunning long range passing.  His surging runs are not as frequent, just more controlled, and I lost count of the times colleagues failed to pick out runs with loose passing.  His ubiquitous influence is very much still the heart-beat of the side, although he has been supplanted by Suarez as the inspirational figure. His level of performances this last season gives one the impression he will be around for a few seasons yet. 6/10

Raheem Sterling:  The lack of depth forced Brendan Rodgers into picking the youngster.  It says a lot about his fearlessness and the impact he made early on, that stories were abound that the club were being forced to offer the youngster improved contract terms as rivals were looking to pounce in the January transfer window.  He has a prodigious work ethic, often working back to support the defender behind him.  One felt as the season went on his struggled as teams began to work him out and as he came up against more physical opponents.  He has the prerequisite 'smarts' to get over those perceived problems as he gains more experience and begins to fill out.  All in all, a promising first season as he took on the mantle of being Liverpool's premier winger scoring his first Premiership goal. 5/10

Jonjo Shelvey:  After some strong early season performances, particularly in the Europa Cup, he dropped out of contention which is hard to quantify considering the form of Joe Allen.  In a season which saw him making his debut for England in the World Cup qualifier at home to San Marino and continued excellence for the under-21s, his absence from the run-in seemed mystifying and it appears sadly, that the talented youngster maybe heading for pastures new.  3/10

Jesus Fernandez Seaz (Suso) - Arguably the most naturally gifted player at the club, with the ability to dribble with the ball close to his feet and a passing range which only his club captain is able to top.  His lack of stature is the only thing holding him back in the Premiership at the moment and on a few occasions he was substituted at half-time. With Coutinho on the scene he has direct competition and one suspects he would rather play in the hole rather on the left had side. 4/10

Fabio Borini:  The Italian striker's first season was decimated by two injuries.  The first of which left the club with one recognised striker and the second cruelly as he'd worked his way back into the contention all but ended his season with a dislocated shoulder. He returned in the last few games to score his first Premiership goal for the club and looked incisive.   He is highly thought of in his homeland as one of the best young strikers and hopefully will push on next season even with Apas and Alberto entering the equation. 3/10

Luis Suarez:  After two and half seasons at Anfield is arguably behind only Messi and Ronaldo respectively as the best players in the world.  The Uruguayan has overtaken Gerrard and is now carrying Liverpool.  Some of his performances have been simply devastating and until Daniel Sturridge arrived he was the Liverpool attack.  We are now in the dangerous position of hoping rather than been relatively certain of his stay and should he leave will be in the position of losing a truly world class player destined to be a great one.   The Uruguayan once again blotted his copy book with his unconscionable act of savagery against Chelsea which brought LFC into disrepute and cost the club with his ban overlapping in next season. 9/10

Daniel Sturridge:  His explosive start to his Liverpool career only made fans wonder what might have been had he started the season at Anfield alongside Suarez.  The pairing almost pulled the loss at Old Trafford out of the mire with a second-half performance which had fans looking forward to possible Champions League entry.  The £12million looks money well spent and Anfield could be a happy home for the England International.  He has a disturbing knack of picking up injuries just as he appears to be pushing on and was injured playing for England in the close season and we can only hope that he’ll be back in time to have a pre-season, especially with Suarez still serving his ban.  6/10

Osama Assaidi:  Difficult to fathom just why Brendan Rodgers bought the ex-Heerenveen winger.  We saw enough of him in flashes to see his potential coming off the bench.  There were occasions when the Liverpool bench looked sparse with youngsters helping to fill the breach and one could only wonder whether the Moroccan International had failed to impress a manager who spent £3million to beat of interest from clubs in Holland and the Premiership in training.  1/10

Philippe Coutinho:  The Brazilian has already become a firm favourite with supporters taking to the Premiership like a duck to water.  Able to play in colleagues on the run and play pinpoint passes from wide or central positions.  He has built himself an upwardly mobile place in the club stats having already a number of assists and goals.  Possessing the ability to beat defenders with just a drop of the shoulder, he has a burst of pace over the first five yards and as he proved an undoubted match winner who combines well with Enrique and his fellow South American Suarez and with Sturridge there relationship appeared almost telepathic.  As time goes on he'll become more combative, which will enable him as with Suarez to become one of the team's leaders,  7/10

Notable others:  Samed Yesil showed in flashes he could be poacher of some repute with a sharpness in the box and a directness in front of goal which saw him start in the Europa League.   Unfortunately, injury finished his season just as he was looking to kick on. Anyone watching Jordan Ibe’s progress since his debut for the under-18s in 2012 will not be surprised by his impressive debut in the final game of the season against QPR when he laid on an assist for Philippe Coutinho.  Definitely one for the future.

Loaned players:

Player
Team
Appearances
Goals
 
Andy Carroll
* West Ham (Sold to West Ham for a reputed £15 million with add ons)
24
7
Michael Ngoo
Heart of Midlothian
17
5
Daniel Pacheco
SD Huesca
17
4
Jack Robinson
Wolverhampton Wanderers
11
0
Jay Spearing
Bolton (voted player of the season by Supporters’ Association and also scooped the club’s player of the season)
37
2

Brendan Rodgers:  Next season will be the barometer used to measure whether Liverpool are going forward under  Rodgers or whether his 180 page document was merely a false dawn written by a manager/coach swimming against the tide of expectation.  At our best we've played some of the most thrilling and dynamic football in the League and it's to Rodgers credit, his positive outlook and his fervent belief that football should be played in an entertaining manner.  

He buys similar bodied players in stature which sometimes leaves us susceptible against the more physical teams.  He's plagiarized the Barcelona play book, but even they recognise the need for steely resolve and have Sergio Busgetts and Alex Song at the bottom of the midfield doing the dirty work and no surprise that these two are physically taller and stronger in the tackle than their more celebrated colleagues, although they still felt short to the more powerful Bayern.  Swansea while keeping Rodgers basic philosophy, have added more power to their play at both ends which enabled them to compete and become a force away from home.  We need to adapt to different philosophies of play as this is not La Liga where most teams play football without the physical threat.  Even Chelsea with the wonderfully gifted talents of Mata, Oscar and Hazard have found it difficult to play all three, in the Premiership and it was the same for Liverpool at St. Mary's and a good portion of the home game against Spurs where we struggled to live with their power and pace having started with Downing and Coutinho supplementing Sturridge and Suarez leaving the midfield bereft. 

Gone are the days where Steven Gerrard is going to carry the team on his own and Rodgers must look long-term for his captain's replacement which will allow him to be more strategic in the way he deploys him.  We have been found wanting in some games pure and simple because of the lack of depth and quality in the squad.  Rodgers needs to add ready-made quality to the squad and it's the one thing he should've learn from Suarez who was a quality player before his arrival. 
 
There are positives.  We could and should have beaten Man City twice and Man United at home.  A lot has been made of our failure to beat those above, but we more than held our own and it is how Rodgers channels this into moving the team forward that will set out whether we compete with the big four.

We let ourselves down in home matches against WBA and Aston Villa which turned out to be vital points dropped, in our quest for European qualification.  All in all, with Rodgers at the helm, the club has managed to stabilize itself following the traumatic last few years.  On the field we haven't gone forward as much we would’ve liked, but with the glittering skills of Luis Suarez he knows that should he add some more talent to the team he may on the verge of moving the side into contention for a top four position. Should he not be supported by the board, then 2013-2014 may see us lose Reina and Suarez and our ability to compete at the top end.  One would like to see us succeed with a British manager at the helm and hopefully Brendan Rodgers is that man.  6/10

The Board:  The board haven't been backwards in coming forward, having backed managers financially, but we need to move on to the next level.  Critically, at the start of the season their failure to back the manager in the transfer market left us short upfront.  The drive to balance the books saw Andy Carroll go to West Ham on loan and no viable alternative come in.  Alternately, the success of Daniel Sturridge proves the club could've returned to the Champions League ahead of schedule and one wonders whether it was a lack of foresight on their part or just naivety in not knowing enough about the game to recognise how difficult it would be to challenge on any front with one top striker, all be it a world class one.  It begs the question, as to just just how much control Rodgers had in terms of transfers at the start of last season.

The summer transfer window will see whether the board understands the rationale of bringing in top players to help Gerrard and Suarez or stick rigidly to their mantra of bringing young players with potential rather than world-class players to take us to the next level.  Liverpool are at least four players short of being able to build an aura of authority to consistency challenge for a top four position and I challenge John W. Henry, Tom Werner, Ian Ayres and co to work with Brendan Rodgers to achieve that this summer. 

Hopefully the board shares Steven Gerrard's views in what needs to be done.  "We're not far away," said Gerrard speaking after the win against Villa.

"There will be some improvements in the summer to the squad and we believe we can then put in a better challenge for the top four next season. “We know what our problem is and it's inconsistency.

For the majority of the games [last season] we have played well enough to be higher up the league than we are, but when you look at performances like Southampton, Aston Villa at home, West Brom away, Arsenal at home; there's a handful of games there that this team hasn't turned up. That's the reason why we are sitting where we are in the table. But there have been some fantastic performances, ones that are well worth a top-four finish."

"If you have players like Coutinho and Suarez in your team then you win games," said the 32-year-old. "Ever since I was a player as a kid, you always find it easier to play alongside quality players. All the way through, Michael Owen, [Fernando] Torres, Suárez, Coutinho, they are the easiest players to play with."  John W. Henry were you listening?
 
The board sacked Kenny Dalglish over his ill-judged support over the racism row with Patrice Evra.  There followed a root and  branch clear out of the club's PR Department,  yet over the Suarez 'Bite Gate' affair the club instead of being seen to act by banning the star striker, they fell foul of not seeing the wider picture.  If we had been blessed with a few more world class players in the locker would the board have seen fit to have issued its own tough ban or even let the player go?  One doesn't want to aim cynicism at their attempts to be fair to the player as the FA in their wisdom and own attempts to lay down the law did not, as the PFA had, offer an olive branch to help the help the player who obviously has a character flaw in his make-up. 5/10

2012-2013 (Review):  The season started with no gargantuan expectations, but through it expectations were raised time and again with performances against the top six clubs.  Time again it was one step forward and two back with under-par performances against Aston Villa and WBA at home and a humiliating performance away to Southampton spelt curtains for the push towards a European place.

Luis Suarez stood head and shoulders above his colleagues and usurped Steven Gerrard as the go to man in the side.  One felt in the first half of season, he and he alone kept us away from the mediocre.  If he came to us as world class talent he finished the season as one of the world's great players, but even his explosive play couldn't get us into the top four.

Liverpool supporters are some of the most knowledgeable in the game and understand the position having seen promising performances against the Manchester United (home and away), Man City (home and away) Spurs (home) and Arsenal (away) and beating Chelsea away.  We threw away game after game, unable to finish off teams.


The lack of depth and was keenly shown up in our Europa Cup performances, where  Rodgers often threw, youngsters into the fray and didn’t look too perturbed after we were summarily dismissed from the competition.

The defence one of strongest the previous season, leaked goals throughout.  Martin Skrtel, a rock, saw his form dissipate to the point that Jamie Carragher regained his place in the twilight of his career.  It was disappointing to see the level of support given to the player who is a top quality defender.  Granted Jamie Carragher came back to provide organisation and leadership, but the goals still leaked and alongside him Agger was lucky not to find himself in the same boat as his normal centre-half partner.  The spine of the team lacked a combative edge and needs to be addressed.

All is all, with the tools on hand, 7th place is about par for the course considering the turn over at the start of the season, but with three undoubted world-class players in the ranks in Reina, Gerrard and Suarez the disappointment felt that we hadn’t at least usurped Everton was keenly felt.  Progress in the second-half of last season lends one to believe that relative progress in 2013-14 is attainable.  5/10

So success for the forthcoming season would be in my eyes a strong push for fourth and even third place and a strong showing in both domestic cup competitions with no European Cup to use as an excuse. 

Monday, 27 May 2013

Panorama: Hillsborough – How They Buried The Truth

I defy anyone to watch the Panorama programme Hillsborough and not get emotional.  It shows a litany of mistakes, lies and ultimately a cover-up which caused pain, distress, heartache and anger for families, friends and supporters.  That the authorities would wilfully confiscate BBC taped coverage shot from eight cameras shows a vindictive and nasty set of human beings who were in charge on the day, led the investigation and the Government of the day and future administration's who stymied any progress by pointing  an accusing finger towards Liverpool fans.

This was the era of football hooliganism and following Heysel, it was easy for the authorities as I have said previously, to use stereotypes through the newspapers led by The Sun, and wilfully block any attempts to get justice for the 96 and their families.

The pain of those who attended the match is still so raw primarily because of the ineptitude of those in charge.  Fans, policemen and ambulance men spoke of the incompetence and the indecision from those on the ground,  but ultimately the decision makers who inescapably showed they were unprofessional and incapable of making decision under pressure and have since hid behind the cloak of seniority and knighthoods in a bid to not face up to their responsibilities.

Anne Williams lost her son Kevin on that fateful day, campaigned tirelessly for justice and for stain to be removed from accusatory fingers of the establishment.

Anne who died recently after a courageous fight against cancer,  was a driving force behind the campaign, and described by Kevin Robinson the former chair of the Hillsborough Justice Campaign,  said she was "an absolutely fantastic lady in every way."

Anne Williams the 24th Hillsborough 24th memorial service

It's Anne and Kevin and the 95 victims and their families that the fight goes on to completely clear their names and bring the real villains that day to task through disciplinary proceedings or criminal convictions.  It's criminal that these people have only felt the heat of public pressure after the release of the report and in line with the vindication of the decisions finally being quashed when these people tell the truth about what really happened that day, and they'll only do that through the wealth of evidence being amassed against them,  they should be relieved of positions they still hold and awards public awards like knighthoods and keys to the city.

One of the unashamed is Sir Norman Bettison, the antithesis to decorum as Anne Williams is heavenly to the same adjective, managed to go under the radar for years until he was named in the Independent  Police Complaints Commission (IPCC) by West Yorkshire Police Authority that he supplied misleading information, in other words he was economical with the truth.  He was still at it last last September when he said that the our fans’ behaviour at Hillsborough made made policing “harder that it needed to be”.

This is not the behaviour we expect of a person of authority, let alone a senior policeman and as such he should relieved of us any awards specifically his knighthood.  His knighthood, awarded for policing and in this regard since the tragedy he has failed abysmally.  A couple of the key indicators for a policeman are:
 
  • conducting initial investigations, gathering evidence, taking statements and complying with relevant legal requirements;
  • gathering, recording and analysing intelligence to achieve community safety and crime reduction objectives and providing crime prevention advice;
One can safely say that Sir Norman Bettison has failed especially in trying to, as the e-petition, relates, in his “alleged attempt to influence the decision-making process of West Yorkshire in the days following the publication of the IPCC report”, therefore his resignation from his post as chief constable of West Yorkshire Police last October and the removal of his honorary fellowship by the John Moores University, should be only the starters.

The inspirational chairwoman of the Hillsborough Family Support Group, Mary Aspinall, said, “It’s great to know that John Moores University has done the right thing.

“Let’s hope now that the next step is the removal of his knighthood.”

The published IPPC report said that Bettison, if he was still on the force, would have “a case to answer for gross misconduct.  That’s why it’s important that we support the move to remove his Knighthood and to this end people should sign the e-petition.


YNWA

Borini or Carroll?

Blog follower Livi posed a question to us last week.  Borini or Carroll?

Well Andy Carroll’s career at Liverpool, looks to be over with reportedly just the ‘big mans’ agreement needed to sign off his move to West Ham.

Taking on board Brendan Rodgers comments following his recent chat with Carroll it does seems the former Newcastle striker will leave for the East London club.

Carroll scores the winner in the 2012 FA Cup Semi-Final


The Liverpool manager said, “It was just a general conversation in terms of the experience of getting out and playing.  He enjoyed that apart from the injury.  At the start of the whole thing was about getting games because he wasn’t going to be a starter here.  We will  talk again with him and the club to see how it all evolves.  It’s one one of those situations where it will probably be resolved a lot quicker than that for both parties.”

We need to add to the striking ranks and whether it’s the return of Carroll or bringing in a striker to replace him the decision has to be taken soon.

Rodgers finished by saying, “It’s a difficult one.  I spoke to him and we had a good chat.  The boy is a talent.  It’s just something we need to assess between now and the end of the window.  In terms of the money, that’s something out of my control.  But he’s a talent so we assess the whole situation.  The objective at the beginning of the season was for him to go out and play.  He’s gone away to think of what we spoke about and we will talk again through the weeks.”

Andy Carroll
Decision time for Carroll

Does that sound like the door has been firmly close on Carroll?  The talk of assessing the whole situation... does that include Fabio Borini’s future too?

It begs the question whether Rodgers wants similar type players all over the pitch or is he open to the flexibility of having a player like Carroll in his ranks?  Flexibility in approach lends itself to being able to adapt to different circumstances.  Even Barcelona, found it difficult to match the intensity and ferocity intertwined with the technical expertise of the German’s and other teams, not possessing the physicality or the stature to combat the different threats even in La Liga which is strange to say as they easily won La Liga, but teams were more combative and structured against them this year and at times they struggled to overcome the challenge.

We need an approach in the transfer market to close the gap with the big four and we may already have a player in Carroll to increase the depth in quality of the squad, but if we do let him go and Borini is seeing as the third striker Rodgers will still needs another option and whether that is by courage of his convictions to go into the transfer market and bring in a quality striker or pitch the likes of Michael Ngoo or Adam Morgan into the fore which would be more in line with the diktat espoused by the Fenway Sports Group.

Borini returned in determined fashioned towards the end of the season producing some impressive cameos and I have for a while suspected we may not as yet seen the skills which have propelled him to the Italian full-squad and why the Italians rate the ex-Bologna striker so highly.

If it were up to me it would be Carroll as he offers a different threat to  any player in the squad and I believe will only improve as he gets stronger and more powerful and as his technique improves with experience his threat levels will rise exponentially. 

Fabio Borini scores his first Anfield goal

Sunday, 19 May 2013

Carra's final farewell Liverpool 1 QPR 0

By David Douglas

After 16 years and his 737th and final appearance for our club Jamie Carragher finally said goodbye to our club this afternoon.

The JC23 emblem being held up from the Kop once Jamie Carragher ran out was a fitting tribute to a great servant to our club.











His leadership influence on the team was underestimated towards the end of his career but his determination to fight back and win his place back in the team halfway through the season typifies his never say die character.

The fact that this was his last game and a celebration of his achievements would not have phased Carragher his whole ethos on football is to win the game and ask questions later, he would have been more disappointed that we didn't treat the game as anything but a testimonial.

There was a real sense of out with the old, in with the new as we gave a full debut to our young winger Jordan Ibe and he grasped the opportunity with both hands causing QPR all sorts of problems with his pace and trickery.

To sum this up Ibe set up the only goal of the game for our little magician Coutinho to score from just outside the area after 23 minutes - how ironic on a significant day for number 23 !!!

Coutinho to add to his repertoire on the day also nearly scored direct from a corner and had another effort blocked by Shaun Derry.

Carragher tried to do a re-enactment of Maradona's "hand of god" goal vs England by attempting to punch in a cross.

He then tried again with a second effort from a rehearsed short free kick set up by Downing.

Carra had a third and ultimately final effort to score a farewell goal from a half volley from 25 yards which he ht sweeter than he had ever hit a football in his life, the shot beat Robert Green convincingly but unluckily hit the post but stayed out.

The rest of the game petered out with us again not taking our chances to win a game more convincingly but we ended the season with a comfortable 1-0 win.

The two things that Jamie Carragher would have been happy about was the clean sheet at the end of the game and the deserved standing ovation he received when he was subbed for the last time 5 minutes from time and on his final lap of honour as a LFC player.


Liverpool: Reina, Johnson, Carragher (Coates 85), Skrtel, Jose Enrique, Downing, Lucas, Henderson, Ibe (Borini 64), Coutinho (Suso 74), Sturridge.
Subs Not Used: Brad Jones, Assaidi, Coady, Wisdom.
Booked: Henderson.
Goal: Coutinho 23.
QPR: Green, Harriman, Onuoha, Hill, Traore, Park (Hoilett 80), Derry, Mbia, Remy (Granero 46), Zamora (Mackie 72), Townsend.
Subs Not Used: Murphy, Da Silva, Ehmer, Bothroyd.
Booked: Hill, Derry, Townsend.
Att: 44,792
Ref: Martin Atkinson (W Yorkshire).


MAN OF THE MATCH: Who else but Jamie Carragher !!!!

Fantastic servant for our club who will be missed but will never ever walk alone.

Thanks Carra, we salute you! YNWA










Sunday, 12 May 2013

Stunning Sturridge Produces Virtuoso Performance


Liverpool stormed out of the blocks looking lively with fringe players playing for their futures backed by the away crowds, numbers swelled as it always is in the capital from the huge London support.  Sturridge again in the absence of Suarez led the line, with Shelvey coming in for jnjured captain finally succumbing to his shoulder problem and with the end of the season nigh Coates and Wisdom came in for Agger and Enrique with Rodgers experimenting with three at the back.

Coutinho in his free role ran the show in the opening 20 minutes, his long range drive parried away by Schwarzer, with the Fulham midfield chasing shadows.  Sturridge put through by Carragher in the inside left channel screwed his shot wide of the mark, Berbatov also shanked a shot wide.

The settling down period after the initial flurry, saw the intensity drop and the vibrancy disappear until Damian Duff worked an opening for a cross for Reither down the Fulham right, who in turn superbly crossed for Berbatov, standing embarrassingly alone to nod in after 32 minutes.

Minutes later Daniel Sturridge ran in behind Aaron Hughes on the end of Wisdom's long ball, flicked the ball back over Hughes entering the area, squared him up, before turning him inside out and clinically dispatching a right-footed finish.  It was the finish of a craftsman.

For all the controlled possession, the goal came from a long punt up field and a piece of impudence from the gifted striker showing up the lack of cutting edge in the first half, but why there is no substitute for a potent striker.

The defensive problems in trying to contain Duff and Reither down the Fulham right led Rodgers into replacing Wisdom with Enrique, forgoing the sweeper system and moving back to the conventional 4-4-2.
Daniel Sturridge started the second-half like a man possessed with a couple of sparkling runs. The second of which, he turn past his marker and then ghosted past three defenders before, being shepherded away from goal.   Another run by Johnson from the right saw him surge into the Fulham area before rounding Hangleland, his cut back just failing to reach Shelvey.

In quick succession we could've easily had decisions go against us.  First, Johnson’s over the top tackle might have seen him collect red instead of yellow and a handball claim against Lucas on another day could very well have been given a penalty.

Two minutes later Sturridge gave Liverpool the lead, as Coutinho's deflected shot fell in his path, the young striker arched his body to the right to place the ball coolly into the far corner of the net.


Daniel Sturridge takes the acclaim
Sturridge working his proverbial socks off, then robbed Hangleland and saw his shot well saved by Schwarzer.   The striker now on fire, stormed into the Fulham half, leaving all behind him, bearing down on goal with the intent again of curling the ball inside the far corner, but saw his shot well saved,  when a simple roll across to either Countinho or Shelvey would've seen off Fulham.

The miss almost proved costly, but for Pepe Reina pulling off a stunning save from Aaron Hughes header.

Liverpool were slicing through Fulham at will and Borini on for Shelvey sliced past two defenders cutting in from left, to see his stunning effort smack against the post.

Fortunately, Sturridge atoned for his miscalculation,  fastening on to a stunning Phillipe Coutinho pass before deftly chipping the ball over Schwarzer to give Liverpool a well-deserved win and his sixth goal in his last four games.

Kop-post Man of the Match:  Daniel Sturridge – Led the line with enthusiasm and vigour and direct in everything his did.  While, the stunning Coutinho had arguably equal claims for man of the match, it was Sturridge brilliant first goal which brought us level at a time when we appeared for all our possession as in the West Ham and Everton games that we would again struggle to create clear openings.

As the manager stated he can be greedy, but one feels that he is on a mission to prove himself a worthy striker and that will dissipate over time, in terms of passing to his team mates once he feels more secure with his place in the team.  With Suarez out he will get a continued run in the side at the start of next season, thus he can look onwards and upwards.

* Sturridge has reached 10 Premier League goals quicker (13 games) than any other Liverpool player beating Fowler and Torres (18) and had now scored 11 goals in fifteen games.

Critical Eye:  A soft goal given away with Berbatov standing alone in the box to head the ball home in between two defenders, Carragher and Johnson.  We need to cut that frailty out of our play next season and the need for a strong firm defence is obvious in Brendan Rodgers second season, which will obviously be more critiqued that his first season at Anfield.

Good to see Connor Coady getting on for a few minutes towards the end and the highly rated centre-half Lloyd Jones getting on the bench.

Manager’s comments:  “Daniel was outstanding.  He scored three goals and he could have had maybe six.”


"If he keeps improving, keeps training well, then I think he will have an outstanding couple of years for us.
"He's not perfect. He should have squared one when he was through. But he was looking for his hat-trick, he's a goal scorer, and to be greedy you've got to be good. He's an outstanding player."

Team:  25 Reina, 2 Johnson, 16 Coates, 23 Carragher, 47 Wisdom (Jose Enrique – 46 mins), 10 Coutinho (Coady – 88 mins), 14 Henderson, 19 Downing, 21 Lucas, 33 Shelvey (Borini – 77 min), Sturridge

Subsitutes: 1 Jones, 3 Jose Enrique, 35 Coady, 51 Jones, 11 Assaidi, 29 Borini, 30 Jones

Referee: Mark Halsey

Attendance: 25,640

Monday, 6 May 2013

Liverpool 0 Everton 0

The 220th Merseyside Derby ended as a damp squib with the realisation,  not that we didn't already know,  that these two giants are now relegated to also-rans behind Manchester and London.

Steven Gerrard towered over the game like a colossus showing his full  range of passing all the facets of his game which for a decade has made him the pre-eminent all round player in the country.  He was  everywhere, tackling back, driving the midfield and surging forward as of yesteryear.

For the future, Coutinho was equally exciting.  We know he possesses devastating vision, especially seeking out his frontmen, but he showed Everton's 'dog's of war' midfield that he was up for the fight, bouncing of tackles and shimmying away almost ghost like away from tackles.  He doesn't flinch, often hitting the ground and bouncing back like a rubber ball showing a robustness which players with silky skills are not normally renowned for.

One of his mesmeric through balls found Sturridge who in trying to round the keeper found his route blocked by Tim Howard. Sturridge has many talents,  but one feels he sometimes tries to score the perfect goal when he could just prod the ball home or lay the ball off to one of his colleagues running off him as he failed to do a couple of times in the game.  But all in all, he's been a potent force since his £12million signing.


Jamie Carragher greeted by David Moyes

The clear cut chances were ours, Steven Gerrard coming close twice.  In the first-half he had a goal bound shot superbly blocked by Jagielka and his power-house run was cleverly picked out by Sturridge in the second-half, having rounded the keeper, his shot was easily picked off by the covering Distin.

It was probably one of the most toothless derbies in terms of passion for a long while, with Everton content with a draw and Liverpool missing Suarez cutting edge.  That being said, Everton will feel they peeved at having Distin's goal wiped out for Anichebe's foul on Reina.  Foul or not the referee's whistle sounded long before the ball hit the back of the net.

Liverpool had the more clear cut openings, but couldn't quite hit the target when it mattered.

Kop-Post Man of the match:  Steven Gerrard - At his imperious best, showing the full range of his passing, short and long and kept the Everton midfield quiet with his attacking verve and thunderous tackling.   Unlucky not to have had at least one goal and was Liverpool's most potent goal threat.   Once again,  showed what big shoes he'll leave when he finally vacates the Liverpool midfield.

Critical eye:  In a game which needed a flash of inspiration, Stewart Downing was not going to be that man.  He flatters to deceive to often, running up blind alleys and for a player so renowned for his crossing he very rarely threatens with his crossing or tears his opposing full-back apart.   For me, although he undoubtedly improved in the second half of the season, one feels he has been an overwhelming disappointment.  I am minded by an old quote when thinking about Downing "if you lick the lollipop of mediocrity once, you're stuck for ever."  I would be surprised to see him as a regular starter next season.

With the outside possibility of Europa qualification through the league still a possibility it was disappointing to see Skrtel come on and not use his aerial threat upfront as a plan b option or not replacing Downing with the tricky and pacey Assaidi or even in using Shelvey.  Losing to Everton is bad at anytime, but to my way of thinking the aim should've been to win and with a better goal difference, there's always the possibility of putting some pressure on them rather than taking the easy option in the last ten minutes.   Disappointing!


Memorable moment:  The Kop holding up cards which said thanks to their neighbours for the support over Hillsborough and the families of the 96 and Jamie Carragher's final appearance in a Merseyside Derby.

Team: 25 Reina, 2 Johnson, 3 Jose Enrique,  5 Agger, 23 Carragher, 8 Gerrard, 10 Coutinho, 14 Henderson (Borini -66 mins), 19 Downing (Skrtel - 79 min), 21 Lucas, 15 Sturridge

Substitutes: 1 Jones, 16 Coates,  37 Skrtel,  33 Shelvey, 11 Assaidi, 29 Borini,  30 Suso

Ref: Michael Oliver
Attendance: 44, 991